As the ongoing bull market is in its eighth year, many "experts" advise investors to hedge their stock portfolios by purchasing put options of their stocks. SPY is in its eighth year, it has become the second-longest in history.
Thus it has made most investors quite nervous that the top may be just around the corner. Moreover, it has led many "experts" to advise individuals to hedge their stock portfolio by purchasing put options of their stocks. This is as dangerous as a piece of advice can be. In this article, I will illustrate that purchasing put options to hedge a stock portfolio is a losing strategy, with the potential to devastate the returns of a portfolio.
First of all, I am sure that some investors like the idea of hedging their portfolio with put options. After all, if the market rises, they will profit; if it falls, they will minimize their losses thanks to the put options. Therefore, it seems like there is nothing to dislike about this strategy. Unfortunately, there is no such thing as a free meal, particularly in investing. Just like in the insurance of your car and your home, the premium you pay on a regular basis tends to offset the compensation you receive much less frequently.
This is exactly the case with buying put options. Most of the time they expire worthless and thus the premium paid upfront is lost. These losses aggregate quite fast and thus greatly impair the long-term returns of a portfolio. Investors should realize that the market spends most of its time in an uptrend or range-bound mode while it spends much less time in a downtrend.
Therefore, put options that are at the money or out of the money usually expire worthless. Moreover, if one attempts to purchase them during the initial phase of a downturn in order to prevent further losses, one will have to pay a markedly high premium as the latter grows remarkably with volatility. Consequently, the only way investors can buy cheap insurance is to buy the put options during a calm period for the market. However, as evidenced in the ongoing bull, the market can remain calm much longer than you can afford paying for put options.
I have used its historical stock prices of the last 10 years and have assumed that a portfolio is hedged in January every year with the purchase of put options that expire in next January. Of course, one could purchase puts that expired sooner and roll them over every few months but that would result in higher total premiums this is just a matter of math and higher fees, as there would be more transactions and the options of the other months are less liquid for some stocks.
I have assumed that the put options are slightly out of the money in order to mitigate the losses of the strategy. If I had used in-the-money options, the losses would have significantly increased. The results are shown below:. It should be noted that many shareholders of this stalwart hold the stock for its exceptional dividend growth record. This is certainly a devastating result for the dividend-oriented investors, who should take this seriously into account before rushing to purchase "insurance" for their portfolio.
It is also prominent from the above table that the put options proved profitable in only two out of the last 10 years. Therefore, it becomes apparent that the benefit of this hedging strategy is somewhat random even in a major downturn.
If investors tried to implement the strategy via monthly put options instead of yearly ones, they would eliminate this randomness of the strategy but their fees and commissions would multiply while the total premiums would greatly rise.
Moreover, the premiums paid for the put options would skyrocket during the core of the downturn whereas they were much lower in the above scenario, as they were bought before the escalation of the crisis. As the market spends much more time in bull or flat markets than in bear markets, it is only natural that buying put options to hedge a portfolio is a losing strategy. If a portfolio consists of good stocks with promising growth prospects, limited amount of debt and sound valuation, then it only has to lose from such a strategy.
I recognize that fierce market downturns can be remarkably painful to most investors, who thus seek a way to mitigate that pain. However, those who cannot tolerate that pain, which shows up for about 1. This is actually the advice of Warren Buffett to all those investors who do not possess exceptional stock-picking skills. To sum up, buying put options to hedge a stock portfolio greatly reduces its returns in the long run. Every single day or week that passes without anything extraordinary, the remaining value of the put options declines.
This should certainly deter the dividend-oriented investors. Therefore, investors should do their best to select stocks with promising growth prospects and attractive valuation and keep their confidence in their stocks even during a fierce bear market, as long as the long-term prospects of their stocks do not change materially. This is the only strategy in order to succeed as an investor in the long term. Of course, the results of the above strategy will vary depending on the stock you choose.
However, if you have chosen the right stocks for your portfolio, buying puts will always be a losing strategy in the long term. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it other than from Seeking Alpha. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Summary As the ongoing bull market is in its eighth year, many "experts" advise investors to hedge their stock portfolios by purchasing put options of their stocks. However, this is a losing strategy in the long term.
Want to share your opinion on this article? Disagree with this article? To report a factual error in this article, click here. The chat platform is currently undergoing maintenance. To see the chat, try to refresh in about minutes. Chat is not supported in your browser version. Please upgrade your browser or use a different browser, such as Google Chrome.More...